
Seeking Justice
Virginia Forum Best Book Prize, (2026, Winner)
The amazing story of one illegally enslaved Virginia family’s dauntless legal appeal for freedom
Before the Civil War brought emancipation to the South, some enslaved people managed to use the legal system—the same one that had concocted and long perpetuated their bondage—to sue for their freedom from owners who unlawfully held them in slavery. In Seeking Justice, Daniel Thorp tells the story behind Unis v. Charlton’s Administrator, one of the most extensive of these freedom suits in all of American history.
It began when a woman, known only as Flora, was born in Connecticut and sold into slavery in Virginia. Her children sued, and over more than thirty years, four cases involving almost fifty plaintiffs moved through the Virginia court system before finally reaching a conclusion in 1855. Seeking Justice narrates this remarkable saga, illuminating Black Americans’ legal literacy and shining a light on the unusual permutations of the antebellum judicial world and the courage it took for Flora’s family to plunge into the legal heart of a slave society.
A masterful study. Thorp traces a Black family’s tireless struggles to free themselves, offering remarkable testimony to the ingenuity and resilience of enslaved people in the antebellum United States.- Richard Bell, University of Maryland, author of Stolen: Five Free Boys Kidnapped into Slavery and Their Astonishing Odyssey Home
Thorp successfully brings to light, for the first time, the full complexity of the largest and most protracted freedom suit in Virginia's history, giving an excellent sense of the nineteenth-century legal landscape that his subjects encountered. It is the story of one family’s fragile oral history vs. Virginia law—with all its weighty institutions, statutes, and legal culture. A laudable achievement.- Ted Maris-Wolf, College of William & Mary, author of Family Bonds: Free Blacks and Re-enslavement Law in Antebellum Virginia, Ted Maris-Wolf, College of William & Mary, author of Family Bonds: Free Blacks and Re-enslavement Law in Antebellum Virginia
- Emerging Civil WarA welcome addition to the growing historiography on slavery and law. Its contents will be useful to academics in their research, as well as to history enthusiasts eager to learn the many complexities of the peculiar institution and enslaved peoples' 'unquenchable desire . . . to gain their freedom and the determination and ingenuity with which they sought to do so.'

